The Amendment 3 ballot summary includes a December 31, 2026 residency date. It also sets out proposed changes to homestead exemptions and non-homestead assessments.
The sentence most relocators haven't seen
The Florida Division of Elections lists the measure under the title "Increased Homestead Exemption; Lower Cap on Increases in Non-Homestead Property Assessments." It would raise the homestead exemption for all non-school taxes to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028, with inflation adjustments after that. The official summary also says that people who are not Florida residents on December 31, 2026, will receive the existing homestead exemption when they qualify, "with the increased homestead exemption beginning with the fifth year of exemption, to the extent permitted by the U.S. Constitution."
The Legislature passed the joint resolution, CS/HJR 1-F, on June 2, 2026, during a special session. The ballot language voters will see was rewritten after a court challenge. The Florida Policy Institute reports that a circuit judge ordered the change. If voters approve it, the amendment takes effect January 1, 2027.
The Florida Senate's announcement confirms that school-board levies are left out of the larger exemption.
Florida TaxWatch estimates that a home assessed above the exemption would save about $1,035 in 2027 and $2,085 in 2028, using a statewide-average non-school rate of 10.5 mills. Actual savings depend on local rates.
The gap this would add to
Windermere already has a tax gap between long-time owners and recent buyers, and the date rule would add to it. At a West Orange forum covered by the West Orange Times & Observer, Orange County Tax Collector Scott Randolph said market value in the county has risen 104% since 2017, while taxable value has risen 30%. The reason is Save Our Homes, which limits annual increases in a homestead's assessed value to 3%.
Randolph gave a concrete example. From 2020 to 2025, Orange County's median market value rose by $150,000. Yet a median-valued homeowner who stayed in the same house the whole time pays only about $193 more per year than five years earlier. He told the Observer that the system "pushes property taxes onto people coming into the marketplace for the first time — whether that be retirees moving from out of state, a new homeowner, a younger person or somebody mid-career moving to Florida for the first time."
He also said Amendment 3 would not close that gap. Save Our Homes itself would not change. TaxWatch notes that the 3% cap and portability stay as they are. The cap the amendment lowers is a different one that applies to non-homestead property.
What Windermere's budget says about who pays next
The second part of the story is what the town does if its revenue drops. Windermere adopted an operating millage rate of 3.7425 mills for fiscal 2026–27. That is 4.27% above the 3.5893-mill rollback rate, on a total budget of $12,464,394.17, according to the town's September 16 final budget hearing agenda. Town Manager Robert Smith told the Observer that the General Fund is about $9.6 million, of which $4.6 million comes from property taxes. That is close to half.
Public safety makes up 35% of the town's overall budget, which includes a contract with the Ocoee Fire Department for fire and EMS service. Smith has said he does not want to cut public safety, so other spending would come under pressure first. During budget talks, sidewalk work was cut from $100,000 to $20,000 and signage from $44,000 to $5,000. Smith said sidewalk extensions would wait until the amendment's outcome is known, the Observer reported in its coverage of the town's event debate. He told the September forum that capital improvement projects would have to be delayed for another 10 years.
The same budget season shows how tight things already are. Light Up Windermere and Food Truck Nights were both proposed for elimination or suspension. The council then told staff to restore funding for Light Up Windermere, with holiday lighting capped at $25,000, down from about $35,955 the year before.
If a shortfall is filled with higher rates or fees, the cost lands on whoever still has taxable value. TaxWatch notes the amendment does not stop local governments from raising millage up to legal limits or increasing fees. The Tax Foundation lists the groups that would carry higher rates: remaining taxable homestead value, newer Florida residents, second homes, rentals, and commercial property. Randolph said that once more than half of homeowners have $0 taxable value, "new homeowners, renters and commercial property owners will pay for the increases to the millage rates." He also said long-time owners could see non-ad valorem charges such as fire assessments. He noted that how much revenue a city or town loses depends on its tax base, including how much of it is homesteaded and how much is commercial.
At the West Orange Chamber of Commerce's September 30 Community Conversation, Smith said the people who lose out would be "the actual taxpayers that moved over here," people who came for "a quality of life and a level of service that is going to be diminished," as the Observer's Q&A records.
Countywide, Orange County's fiscal 2026–27 budget book estimates a loss of about $275 million a year in property tax revenue once the changes are fully phased in.
For second homes and investment properties
The non-homestead assessment cap would drop from 10% to 5% a year. The Tax Foundation and Randolph named second homes and rentals among the properties likely to carry any millage increase.
The broader Orlando market
In August 2026, the Orlando Regional REALTOR Association reported 4.9 months of supply, still under its six-month benchmark for a balanced market. Homes averaged 64 days on market, the same as July, and the single-family median price was $436,456, compared with $435,069 a year earlier, according to the association's monthly market narrative. These are region-wide figures, not Windermere-only numbers.
A few questions buyers are asking
Does Amendment 3 change Save Our Homes portability? No. TaxWatch says the 3% cap and portability stay as they are.
Does the larger exemption reduce school taxes? No. School-board levies are excluded.
How big is the change statewide? TaxWatch cites the July 2026 Revenue Estimating Conference forecast of $45.84 billion in local tax reductions over five years.
What happens if it fails on November 3? None of the changes in the ballot summary would take effect, and Windermere's sidewalk extensions would no longer be waiting on the result.
This post is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Please confirm how any of these rules apply to you with a qualified tax professional or attorney.
If you are planning a move to Windermere and want to talk about the house itself and what you hope to do with it, I would be glad to talk it through. Reach out to Soraya Tamaddon. Let's Connect.